Make My Cake

Vendor type

Cakes & Bakeries

Address

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Jr. Boulevard, New York, NJ 10030

Phone

(212) 234-2344

Website

makemycake.com

Opening hours

Mo 08:00-18:00; Tu-Fr 08:00-19:00; Sa 09:00-19:00; Su 09:00-17:00

Data checked

October 28, 2026 (OpenStreetMap)

Before You Book

Couples usually book cake shops and bakeries 4–6 months ahead. Ask:

• Do you offer tastings, and how much do they cost?
• Is pricing per slice, and what is the minimum order?
• What flavors and fillings do you offer, and can you make allergy-friendly cakes?
• Do you deliver and set up? Is there a delivery fee?
• Can the cake handle heat or an outdoor reception?

All 8 questions to ask →

Tips for Booking Cake Shops and Bakeries

• A small display cake plus kitchen sheet cakes is a common way to save.
• Buttercream usually costs less than fondant and tastes better to most guests.
• Order for about 85–90% of your guest count; not everyone eats cake.

Getting several quotes? Line them up in the quote comparison tool and check the contract red flags before you pay a deposit.